TPA bullies score own goal against youth worker
Note: Cross-posted to Liberal Conspiracy
Hot on the heels of the Guardian’s excellent Tax Gap series, LabourList’s Derek Draper sparked a shouting match - real and online - when he invited the TaxPayers’ Alliance to condemn corporate tax avoidance. He pointed out - quite reasonably - that corporate tax avoidance increases the burden on those ordinary taxpayers that the TPA claims to represent. But the TPA’s campaign director, Mark Wallace, complained that Draper’s tone was quite unreasonable - and added: “Corporate tax avoidance is a rational response to an overly complex and burdensome tax code.” So no condemnation there.
I find the spectre of being shouted at by Draper less menacing than the TPA’s own sneering condenscension towards seemingly everyone involved in providing public services. Back in August 2008, the TPA’s “grassroots co-ordinator” Tim Aker (salary undisclosed) took exception to Moray Council advertising for a “Street Football Co-ordinator” (salary £19,887), who would work “to improve the health and well being of children and young people in Moray” and be “willing to travel and work unsociable hours”.
“Can you contain the rage?” he raged. “This is unbelievable. Councils now engaging in planning and funding ‘street football’. All you need for football is a few jumpers for goalposts and a ball… Believe you me when I say this job is going in our non-job report in December.”
And, true to his word, it did.
The TPA loves these surveys - they can be counted on to generate outraged national and local headlines across the country. (Its most recent survey “exposed” council middle management pay - except it managed to skew the statistics by including teachers.)
But the Scottish national and regional press didn’t play ball. “Council shows group red card over non-job claim,” was the Press and Journal’s headline, and it came up with the novel idea of reporting what the council as well as the TPA had to say.
The Sunday Herald went further. Far from being ashamed, Moray Council was proud of its street football scheme. The post was part-time and so the real salary was only half of that advertised, of which Moray Council provided just £3,000. Grampian Police, Grampian Fire and Rescue Service, and several private companies funded the remainder. (If the TPA had bothered to look - nothing too strenuous, a Google search would have sufficed - they would have quickly discovered why Grampian Police were among the scheme’s keenest backers.)
It’s worth reading Moray Council’s comments to the Herald in full, because they pretty much spell out everything that’s wrong with TPA “research”:
“More than 70 young people attend weekly street football games on Friday and Saturday evenings in Moray. There has been a marked reduction in the instances of anti-social behaviour - vandalism, teenage alcohol abuse and graffiti - in these targeted areas since the introduction of street football, saving many thousands of pounds.
“I realise that the TaxPayers’ Alliance need to grab headlines to attract the donations that keep them in a job, but their poor research lets them down. All they have done is scan for job adverts and picked out those that sound quirky.
“Far from being the self-appointed scrutineers they set out to be, the TaxPayers’ Alliance appear to have become a cash-generating body whose raison d’etre is to generate puff to keep their staff in a job. What a pity, they could be so much more useful.”
Posted by Clifford Singer at 11:38am on 5 February 2009
Tags: Not yet assigned